Being a Good Member of the Community

By  on  

Disclaimer:  I've been waiting, a long, long time to write a post like this.  Passion may be present...

A man stands up with a sheepish smirk, sweat visible. "My name is David Walsh", the studly newcomer said, wearing his Arsenal jersey like a suit of armor.  "I'm a a member of the MooTools Development team and community.  I worked with SitePen and consider myself a member of the Dojo community as well.  I work at a company widely considered the 'web freedom fighters' called Mozilla.  I am a proud member of the JavaScript and front-end community."

At this point in his development life, that about summed him up.  At (almost) 29 years old, his story was quite remarkable:  grew up in a tech-oblivious area, taught himself HTML, CSS, and JavaScript at 14, went to small colleges to get his Associate and Bachelor degrees, experimented with front end technologies while his friends went out and partied, and worked tirelessly to learn everything he could about front end development.  The more he tried, the more he realized how much of a noob he was.  The more he learned, the more he realized he had so much more to learn.

Those are the first two paragraphs from my in-progress memoir titled Memoirs of a Geisha Walsha.  All jokes aside, over the past five years, I've had a quite an experience with MooTools, Dojo, and Mozilla communities.  I'm not the most talented developer in the world but I tend to fit in well with different communities.  In working within each of those communities, I've seen what works, what doesn't, and what ... the hell.  Here are a few thoughts on my experiences in these communities and how you can be an ideal member.

Don't Be an Asshole

The number one thing that brings a community down, and brings a member's credibility down, is being an asshole.  You know the guy.  His code is always better.  His idea is always smarter.  His opinion is always right.  His mouth probably needs a punch, too.  Being an asshole in a community is just about the worst thing you could do.  You turn off other contributors, you alienate yourself from everyone else, and your opinions are instantly disregarded, even if they're good.

The biggest problem is that assholes don't recognize that they're assholes, and usually continue their rampage while loads of valuable community members leave.

Find a Role, Be Good at It

Finding your role in a community is the best way to establish yourself.  Whether your strengths are documenting, providing general IRC or mailing list help, fixing bugs, creating new functionality, or creating plugins, you're an important part of the community.  

No one of those roles is any more important!


Being good at and taking on a specific role provides stability within the community and positions you as a point person for other people.  Other community members with the same skill set will look up to you and you'll be able to help them grow.

Include, Don't Exclude

This simple rule takes on a number of different meanings:

  • Don't exclude known members of other communities; don't be adversarial
  • Don't exclude members of your own community that are known for different roles;  let others dip their hands in all pots
  • Don't exclude new people:  every potential new member of the community has value

Exclusionary practices by any member of a community reflects poorly on all member of the community.

Branch Out

Keep tabs with, interact, and become a member of other similar communities.  Doing so provides the opportunity to learn from other communities, take ideas from code or initiatives, and generally network with people of the same interests.  You'll be surprised at the benefits of doing so, job opportunities being one of those benefits.

Work Hard

Working hard is especially important at the beginning.  Showing other members of the community how hard you're willing to work is a great way to become accepted.  This can't be stressed enough;  effort is the number one source of appreciation in a community.

Those are my initial thoughts.  Let me know if I'm off-base on any of these thoughts.  Most importantly though:  have a positive impact on your community.  No one likes the guy that brings people down.

Recent Features

  • By
    fetch API

    One of the worst kept secrets about AJAX on the web is that the underlying API for it, XMLHttpRequest, wasn't really made for what we've been using it for.  We've done well to create elegant APIs around XHR but we know we can do better.  Our effort to...

  • By
    Write Simple, Elegant and Maintainable Media Queries with Sass

    I spent a few months experimenting with different approaches for writing simple, elegant and maintainable media queries with Sass. Each solution had something that I really liked, but I couldn't find one that covered everything I needed to do, so I ventured into creating my...

Incredible Demos

  • By
    Create a Download Package Using MooTools Moousture

    Zohaib Sibt-e-Hassan recently released a great mouse gestures library for MooTools called Moousture. Moousture allows you to trigger functionality by moving your mouse in specified custom patterns. Too illustrate Moousture's value, I've created an image download builder using Mooustures and PHP. The XHTML We provide...

  • By
    Create a 3D Panorama Image with A-Frame

    In the five years I've been at Mozilla I've seen some awesome projects.  Some of them very popular, some of them very niche, but none of them has inspired me the way the MozVR team's work with WebVR and A-Frame project have. A-Frame is a community project...


  1. Alex

    A “Don’t be an Ass Kisser” would definitely have a place in my == list, as I tend to dislike people who, without much knowledge, talent or even luck, get happier += $

    and worked tirelessly learn everything

    and worked tirelessly to learn everything

  2. Well said David.

    Thanks for the advice.

  3. “Don’t Be an Asshole” +1

    really nice post on being a good contributor.

    you’ve got a typo btw, ‘Include, Don’t Exclude’

  4. Something about “get out when you are too busy” would be nice. In the Joomla community (where I’m from) there are some excellent contributors, but often times they are burned out, busy, and they aren’t able to work with the new folks enough to get anything worthwhile completed. Then it becomes a political game, trying to work around people who hold the project back. That really hurts the community in a big way.

    Great post, though!

  5. Lyza Gardner from Cloud Four recently blogged in a similar spirit and even used the phrase “Don’t be an asshole”.

  6. I love how you said “community” and not “website forum”. This applies to everything in life for the msot part.

  7. 100 Likes for ” Don’t Be an Asshole ” … Lovely article .. As usual inspired me a lot.

  8. Sam Williams

    I have been a hobbyist for five years and professional developer for about 12 months. I would be absolutely useless without quality communities and I help out as much I can.

    BTW: “No one of those roles is any more important!” (missing the ‘T’) :P – I’m a grammar nazi.

  9. Jesus Bejarano

    lol “Memoirs of a Geisha Walsha” , one of my favorite movie

  10. Don’t be an asshole? Completely agree. Except for when that person might be considered an “asshole” for pointing out someone else’s laziness. The only thing worse than being an asshole is asking a question on a forum or place like stackoverflow that could be answered with a 2 second google search. So in my book, when you read those lazy questions… ashole it up!

  11. “The more he tried, the more he realized how much of a noob he was. The more he learned, the more he realized he had so much more to learn.” – I can relate to this. You’ll never know what’s to be learned next unless you tried or put something to practice.

  12. Daniel

    David, you went and wrote a whole post about me – shucks, I’m blushing! JK, rock on Sir Kid Walsh, rock on.

Wrap your code in <pre class="{language}"></pre> tags, link to a GitHub gist, JSFiddle fiddle, or CodePen pen to embed!