Promise.all for Rejections and Resolves

By  on  

Promises have been an incredible addition to JavaScript; they save us callback hell, make coding async more maintainable, and and allow us to keep track of multiple async processes at a time.  Promise.all comes to mind, allowing us to react when multiple promises have been resolved.  Unfortunately Promise.all only resolves when all promises are resolved, so if any of the promises fail, the catch is called instead of then:

Promise.all([
    Promise.resolve(1),
    Promise.reject(0)
])
.then(() => { console.log('resolved!'); })
.catch(() => { console.log('failed!') });
// >> failed!

This is a problem if you want the same functionality to be executed regardless of if any promise in the array is rejected.  You could provide the same function to then and catch but that could lead to maintenance issues and occasional "WTF IS THIS?!" comments from other engineers.

So what should we do when we want Promise.all to trigger functionality regardless of any rejections?  Jake Archibald has the answer:

Promise.all(promises.map(p => p.catch(() => undefined)));

Each promise's catch callback returns undefined which allows the promise's failure to be handled as success. To prove it works, consider this snippet:

Promise.all([
    // Resolves
    Promise.resolve(1), 
    // Rejects after 2 seconds
    new Promise((resolve, reject) => setTimeout(() => reject(1), 2000))
].map(p => p.catch(() => undefined))).then(() => console.log('done!'));

// >> done!

Despite the second promise being rejected, the Promise.all then is called! In the future we'll be able to use Promise.prototype.finally to more easily handle success and failure.

Thank you to Jake for this awesome trick!

Recent Features

  • By
    Camera and Video Control with HTML5

    Client-side APIs on mobile and desktop devices are quickly providing the same APIs.  Of course our mobile devices got access to some of these APIs first, but those APIs are slowly making their way to the desktop.  One of those APIs is the getUserMedia API...

  • By
    How to Create a Twitter Card

    One of my favorite social APIs was the Open Graph API adopted by Facebook.  Adding just a few META tags to each page allowed links to my article to be styled and presented the way I wanted them to, giving me a bit of control...

Incredible Demos

  • By
    Fix Anchor URLs Using MooTools 1.2

    The administrative control panel I build for my customers features FCKEditor, a powerful WYSIWYG editor that allows the customer to add links, bold text, create ordered lists, and so on. I provide training and documentation to the customers but many times they simply forget to...

  • By
    MooTools Flashlight Effect

    Another reason that I love Twitter so much is that I'm able to check out what fellow developers think is interesting. Chris Coyier posted about a flashlight effect he found built with jQuery. While I agree with Chris that it's a little corny, it...

Discussion

  1. Fred

    Have you tried RQ, from our famous and beloved Douglas Crockford, a great (and tiny) async library?

    http://www.rq.crockford.com/

  2. J

    This was on StackOverflow about a year ago http://stackoverflow.com/a/36115549/1253312

  3. Matt

    Howdy David,

    Nice find! I was really struggling with this until I found this method of handling errors.

    Rather than just leaving the rejected promise as undefined, if you add in a flag in the reject event, you can catch the error message cleanly and process in the then function, eg:

    Promise.all( arrayOfPromises
    					.map(p => p.catch( (err) => err)) )
    		.then(data => {
    			console.log(data); // you also get err thrown in too, yay!
    		});

    Matt

  4. Alexon da Silva Moreira

    Hello, I have these two query using promise.using, with bluebird, I can only execute one or the other, how do I create a promise all to execute the two function promise and also other function.

    I have:

    **** Promise 1 ****
    
    function fntTotalDeRegistros () {
    promise.using (db, () => {
    db.query ('SELECT COUNT (*) FROM CUSTOMER')
    .then ((rows) => {
    rows.forEach ((row) => {
    qtdRegsARQ = row.registers});
    console.log (qtdRegsARQ)
    })
    .then () => db.close ())
    .catch ((error) => {console.log (error), db.close ()});
    })
    };
    
    **** Promise 2 ****
    
    function fntRegisterCli () {
    promise.using (db, () => {
    db.query ('Select * from DB_ICADIS.CLIENTE ORDER BY cli_codigo')
    .then ((rows) => {
    rows.forEach ((row) => {
    ...........
    });
    })
    .then (() => console.log (regsCLI))
    .then () => db.close ())
    .catch ((error) => {console.log (error), db.close ()});
    })
    };
    
    
    **** function 3 *******
    
    function fntRegistrationFtr () {
    regFTR = func.concatLeft ('FTR', 3, '0');
    qtdRegsARQ = func.concatLeft (qtdRegsARQ, 9, '0');
    resFTR = func.concatRight ('RESERVED', 202, '');
    seqARQ = func.concatRight (seqARQ, 6, '0');
    regsFTR = $ {regFTR} $ {qtdRegsARQ} $ {resFTR} $ {seqARQ} \ n;
    console.log (regsFTR)
    return (regsFTR);
    }
    
  5. Jorge

    The method explained in the article would masquerade errors and unhandled exceptions.
    This post should be updated with the solution in here:
    https://stackoverflow.com/a/32979111/3221029

    Plus Promise.finally is already supported.

  6. Daniel Cohen Gindi

    Using Promise.finally will not help you there, as it does not suppress errors.
    Meaning – the Promise will still throw after you’ve chained it with a finally call.
    Using Promise.catch is still your best bet!

Wrap your code in <pre class="{language}"></pre> tags, link to a GitHub gist, JSFiddle fiddle, or CodePen pen to embed!