iOS Mobile Safari Hover Menu Fix

By  on  

One component I'm quite proud of creating is the Mozilla Developer Network's dropdown menu component.  It's elegant, flexible, accessible via keyboard, and relatively compact (though it does require jQuery).  One problem I did notice, however, was that tapping once opened the menu (good) but you'd have to double tap (tap twice) on a submenu link to trigger a move to the link URL.  Not a catastrophic issue but certainly annoying. After a bit of tinkering I came up with a solution which satisfied the annoyance!

The JavaScript

I found out the core issue:  the main menu item was coded to open the submenu upon mouseenter.  While I was grateful that iOS mobile Safari was using mouseenter as simply an open trigger, it was causing users the double tap pain to visit a link in the submenu.  So I took advantage of the touchstart event:

$menuItem.on('touchstart mouseenter focus', function(e) {
    if(e.type == 'touchstart') {
        // Don't trigger mouseenter even if they hold
        e.stopImmediatePropagation();
        // If $item is a link (<a>), don't go to said link on mobile, show menu instead
        e.preventDefault();
    }

    // Show the submenu here
});

Why not touchend?  Unfortunately if the user held their finger down for more than a quick tap, the mouseenter event would trigger.  A bit odd but since I have touchstart as the first event in the listener, I can use stopImmediatePropagation to prevent the mouseenter from ever firing.  What's also nice is I don't have to do any device detection to juggle touchstart and mouseenter, so this is an awesome solution...

...but not a perfect solution.  If you tap and hold the main menu item link, the mobile browser context menu doesn't appear because we've used preventDefault.  I'm still exploring and experimenting so I'll continue to update this post as I search for the holy grail!

Recent Features

  • By
    Write Better JavaScript with Promises

    You've probably heard the talk around the water cooler about how promises are the future. All of the cool kids are using them, but you don't see what makes them so special. Can't you just use a callback? What's the big deal? In this article, we'll...

  • By
    Chris Coyier&#8217;s Favorite CodePen Demos

    David asked me if I'd be up for a guest post picking out some of my favorite Pens from CodePen. A daunting task! There are so many! I managed to pick a few though that have blown me away over the past few months. If you...

Incredible Demos

  • By
    LightFace:  Facebook Lightbox for MooTools

    One of the web components I've always loved has been Facebook's modal dialog.  This "lightbox" isn't like others:  no dark overlay, no obnoxious animating to size, and it doesn't try to do "too much."  With Facebook's dialog in mind, I've created LightFace:  a Facebook lightbox...

  • By
    New MooTools Plugin:  ElementFilter

    My new MooTools plugin, ElementFilter, provides a great way for you to allow users to search through the text of any mix of elements. Simply provide a text input box and ElementFilter does the rest of the work. The XHTML I've used a list for this example...

Discussion

  1. James

    Best solution I’ve seen so far. Tried using touchend, and it was firing twice or more on Android devices. Did play around with a timeout, that worked, but felt wrong. This solution works on everything I’ve tested so far, bar the minor issue of holding down the touch you mention.

  2. Is there anyway to do that without jQuery? I’ve been trying but it doesn’t seem to work:

    menuItem.addEventListener( 'touchstart mouseenter focus', toggleMenu );
    

    And the toggleMenu would be like this:

    function toggleMenu() {
        if(e.type == 'touchstart') {
            // Don't trigger mouseenter even if they hold
            e.stopImmediatePropagation();
            // If menuItem is a link (), don't go to said link on mobile, show menu instead
            e.preventDefault();
        }
        // toggle code here
    }
    

    Sorry if this sound silly, but I’m very much new to javascript.

    Anyway, you’re blog is helping me a lot, thanks!

  3. dan

    any idea how I could trigger the click in this case?

    I’m wanting to show the menu (in my case a tooltip) on touchstart, but I actually follow the link on touchend

  4. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS changing my listener from mouseenter to touchstart immediately solved the problem for me.

    I literally spent an hour fiddling with the CSS because I thought it was something to do with pseudo elements. :/

Wrap your code in <pre class="{language}"></pre> tags, link to a GitHub gist, JSFiddle fiddle, or CodePen pen to embed!