Fancy FAQs with MooTools Sliders: Version 2

Discussion

1. Erhan

   great example, I was using the Accordion to get this effect, but your effect seems to make more sense + it’s much cleaner imo..

   So I will sure be using this, I also like the effect version as I was having the same trouble like the accessible demo.

   One question tho, is the slide something new ? or have I just missed this functionality from the documentation..
2. David Walsh

   Fx.Slide has been around for years! :)
3. Adam Kiss

   Just a quick idea – wouldnt it be better (for sake of user) to add cursor: pointer with javacsript? Because then if JS is turned off, users wont think it doesnt work (since clicking in h3 would do nothing)
4. Erhan

   @David Walsh: hahah, yeah I read your previous version after I commented, just a short-hand for Fx.slide in this version.. didn’t know about that!
5. Alex

   Thanks very much for this David. I’m putting it into a client’s site today and am just experimenting with wrappers around the question/answer pair.
6. Andreas

   if(state) {
   	header.addClass('active');
   } else {
   	header.removeClass('active');
   }
   

   could be much shorter

   header[(state ?'add' :'remove') +'Class']('active');
   
7. David Walsh

   @Adam Kiss: Yep, good idea.

   @Andress: I considered doing that but the code looks horrendous.
8. Sean McArthur

   To help with the “accessible” version, if you initially used answer.slide(‘hide’) instead of answer.slide(‘out’), the hiding would be instantaneous, instead of us watching the accordion collapse on load.
9. David Walsh

   @Sean McArthur: I considered that but you can still see a “flash” of the answers in the time before Moo is fully loaded and the domready event fires. I preferred the fold up effect to the “now it’s here…where the hell did they go?” feel.
10. Jonathan Bennett

    Thanks for the tutorial. I created a sliding FAQ for a project about six months ago, and my solution wasn’t quite as elegant as this one.
11. Ed

    Hi David,

    For a long list of questions I wouldn’t think this would be that optimal for usability.
    I’ve found this jQuery FAQ version which would work better for a longer list of questions.

    http://www.bitrepository.com/demo/fancy-faq/

    Is it possible to do something like that with MooTools as well?

    The main usability problem I see is that you when you start fold out questions things can get confusing, it takes more time to scan through to find a question you’ve glanced over and want to check back again for it.

    With the above linked version you can scan through questions and answers much faster.
12. Ed

    Just found this blog post. :)

    http://davidwalsh.name/smooth-scroll-mootools

    Myself not being a coder, is it difficult to have the light up effect as well applied to a div David?

    Like in the previous lined example?

    Thanks!
13. Chris Bolson

    ED – doesn’t do the highlight effect but I just put this together to simulate the jquery example you linked to:
    http://mooshell.net/a2ZMP/
14. David Walsh

    @Ed: I’m not big on that verison — there’s far to much down, then up, down, then up with the window. Dizzying for me.
15. Chris Bolson

    ….and of course exactly the same thing can be achieved with less code using FX.SmoothScroll as per your other demo that @Ed mentioned.

    Anyway, here is what I got to next: http://mooshell.net/gvY3V/
    Quite a lot less code (I posted my first attempt too soon) and does highlight the answer when it is scrolled to as requested by @Ed :)
16. Chris Bolson

    David, just tested this faq code (your one) with mootools version 1.2.4 and it fails :(
    The faq answers are not being hidden, they just stack up on top of each other.

    This is not the first problem I have encountered with this latest version. As a mootools developer, do you have any idea *why* it doesn’t work?
17. derschreckliche

    answer.slide(state ? 'in' : 'out');
    if (state)  {
        header.addClass('active');
    } else  {
        header.removeClass('active');
    }
    

    how about

    answer.slide('toggle'');
    header.toggleClass('active');
    

    ;)

    And thx for using the .getNext() method, i didn’t know it it’s very useful sometimes!
18. Chris Bolson

    As usual I should investigate things before writing…
    Just found an interesting comment with the reason/solution in the mootools blog about this new version:
    http://mootools.net/blog/2009/10/19/mootools-1-2-4/#more-412
    (see comment by Barryvan)

    Basically this latest release requires you to set the overflow:hidden as per your second demo.
    So this css gets it working in version 1.2.4:
    #faqs div { overflow: hidden;}

    That explains all the probelms I was having yesterday which eventually revert to version 1.2.3 :(
19. Ed

    @Chris Bolson:

    Thank you so much Chris! :)
    I couldn’t get the “To Top” function working at first, but then I noticed the “go_to_top” class was changed to “to_top” and it works great now!
20. Ed

    @David Walsh:

    You’re sitting to close to the screen then. ;)
21. Alex

    Any idea how to get this to work when the FAQ is initially hidden (by another mootools script). The height of the answers is initially ‘auto’ in this scenario (until the H3 is clicked twice).
    It’s not essential for my implementation, but it would be nice-to-have.
22. Evan

    I have a little trick that I used in the past to solve the flicker problem and still keep the page accessible for users who don’t have JS.

    The flicker is because we wait for domready to fire before you can start to collapse the copy.

    What I do is place a class on my body tag .

    Then I place some script right after the body tag that immediately removes the no-script class from the body. Obviously if the user does not have JS the class will remain on the page.

    You can now style your page differently for users who don’t have JS.

    #faqs div { height:0; }
    .no-script #faqs div { height:auto; }
    

    Because you are removing the class before a load or domready event you can get the flicker to pretty much go away.
23. zalun

    I’ll us it on the mobile Mooshell version :D
24. Dave Jones

    Here’s a jQuery version for those of us that prefer that framework :

    $(function() {
    	// 1. hide the faqs
    	$('#faqs h3').next().hide();
    	
    	// 2. show when clicked
    	$('#faqs h3').click(function() {
    		$(this).toggleClass('active').next().slideToggle();
    	});
    });
    
25. Design

    Exactly what I was looking for. Excellent!
26. Crispijn

    I’ve rewritten a couple of lines to make the first div active, visible. This is what I came up with:

    	var i = 0;
    	$$('#faqs h3').each(function(header,i) {
    		var state = false, answer = header.getNext('div');
    		
    		if(i > 0){
    			answer.slide('out');
    		}else{
    			state = !state;
    			header.addClass('active');
    		}
    		
    		header.addEvent('click',function(e) {
    			state = !state;
    			answer.slide(state ? 'in' : 'out');
    			if(state) {
    				header.addClass('active');
    			}
    			else {
    				header.removeClass('active');
    			}
    		});
    		
    		answer.setStyles({
    			overflow: '',
    			height: 'auto'
    		});
    		
    		i++;		
    	});
    

    I’ll hope that this is useful for other readers!
27. David Walsh

    @Crispijn: Why not keep my “core” code the same but simply fireEvent(‘click’) on the first item?
28. Crispijn

    @David Walsh: Haven’t thought about that! That’s even better! Thanks
29. Matt

    Hey guys,

    it’s been some time since i’ve been here but I wanted to know if I had a link within an email can I have this link to the page with the question already open?
30. Martin

    Hi David – or anybody here to help me?

    Is it possible:
    1. Turn the animation off?
    2. Click anywhere to close the open part(s)?

    I´m sitting here and can´t get it right…

    Thanks for help!!

    Martin
31. Eliot Slevin

    i have no experience in js, but is it possible to have one question close when another is opened?

    thanks
32. Vilius

    Is there a simple way to let only one item active ?
• Tony Z

  Great stuff. A couple of things I would be interested in.
  1. Code to show all or hide all answers.
  2. Ability to restrict to only show 1 answer at a time (auto close when another question is selected).

  Any
33. Mert

    good idea and good work. thanks…
34. Dan

    Using this on my site with the following CSS for a nice show hide text change:

    #faqs h3:after	{ content: " - show"; }
    #faqs h3.active:after	{ content: " - hide"; }
    

    Nice one on this simple but powerful little script David! Thanks
• rolandtom

  Dan, great addition!